Latest Menu

Restaurant Hours

Sundays 3:30 - 8pm

Tuesday - Wednesday 3:30-9pm

Thursday-Saturday 3:30- 10pm

Customer Reviews

Holy Tomato has some of the best specialty tomato pie's around, makes my mouth water just thinking about it.

- Rhett, G

The Red Pie is the way to go, no cheese to slow me down!

- Fred, B

Holy Tomato has some of the best specialty tomato pie's around, makes my mouth water just thinking about it.

- Rhett, G

The Staff at Holy Tomato is AWESOME. they have the best pie's in NJ. You won't be disappointed stopping by to fill your belly!

- Jason, L

These Tomato Pie's are amazing. My personal favorite is the Chicago Pie!

- Steve, C